Call of Duty: Modern Warfare is reimagined for a new generation in the latest FPS from Infinity Ward. Is the game worth the Price of entry? Here’s our review round-up.
Following last year’s multiplayer-focused instalment, the Call of Duty franchise returns with a new game from Infinity Ward and a single-player campaign that is the subject of much debate.
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare aims to balance the thrills of combat with a rumination on the nature and effect of modern armed conflict. The game’s critical response suggests mixed results, but a memorable experience nonetheless.
Here is our pick of the best Call of Duty: Modern Warfare reviews, with a particular focus on the single-player campaign.
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare: Review round-up
“When its good intentions coalesce, Modern Warfare feels as if it is offering a tantalising glimpse into the future of the industry’s biggest shooter. You’ll feel this in your fingers as the game breathlessly propels you between its checkpoints under a hail of deafening gunfire until you’re left gasping for air. When they clash, it’s a stark reminder of just how easy it is for an action game to turn tasteless – that’s a direct result of Infinity Ward attempting to tactlessly gamify a variety of war crimes in the service of fashioning a bombastic entertainment experience.”
4/5 – Review by Josh West
“That tension builds up over the course of the campaign, and because the characters are likable, it’s easy to at least consider each one’s view of what’s right. But in the end, all you get is a vague “we all did what we had to do” sentiment rather than anything more substantial or interesting. Quite a bit of what you had to do–as Garrick, as Alex, and as Farah–was unpleasant or distressing, but the questions raised by your actions aren’t interrogated further, especially the questionable side of Price’s approach. Modern Warfare‘s ending isn’t bad, but it is a safe one, leaving you to think on the harder questions yourself.”
7/10 – Review by Kallie Plagge
“It is one of the best linear first-person shooter campaigns I’ve played in a good while, thanks to an exciting pace across its five-ish-hour story that, notably, is always mixing up the gameplay. Sure, we’ve done the run-of-the-mill street battles a million times before in this series, but here you’re never doing them for very long without something unexpected happening. Modern Warfare delights most when it surprises, like when you have to engage in tense close-quarters combat to clean out the enemy from small, multi-story houses – often when it’s pitch-black outside of your night-vision goggles.”
8.2/10 – Review by Ryan McCaffrey
The character performances are fantastic – especially for Captain Price, Farah, and Hadir – who get plenty of screen time and are legitimately interesting, especially how they are woven into the conflict at hand. The story is nicely paced, establishes villains you can’t help but hate, and is engaging from start to finish. I also appreciate how the story and gameplay flow seamlessly from moment to moment without loading screens, much like a Naughty Dog production. I completed the campaign in roughly five hours, yet found I enjoyed watching it more for the twists than actually having a hand in some of the battles.
8.75/10 – Review by Andrew Reiner
“The campaign shoots for the variety of distinctive missions that Call of Duty 4 set trends with. It swaps out on-rails murder fests for missions about cautious infiltration where walking is the default move speed. An early mission called “Clean House” is a favorite. Led by Price, your squad raids a London home occupied by a terrorist cell in search of stolen chemical weapons. The raid plays out like an eerily interactive Zero Dark Thirty as the squad slowly breaches bedrooms and stacks up in cramped stairwells.”
80/100 – Review by Morgan Park
Attack of the Fanboy
“There are many moments of genuine heart mixed in among the chaos and violence. With the story jumping from one point of view to another, the player always has a fresh perspective on the events that are unfolding. Each character receives their own moments of significance, though more could have been done to develop some of them beyond the default Soldier personality. However, when the game does focus in on specifics it does so with care and what feels like a true feeling of how important these events can be in the real world.”
4.5/5 – Review by Kyle Hanson
“This game is so thoughtful that it would be a shame if players skipped the single-player campaign and headed straight for multiplayer, which is a great experience as usual. Ultimately, I think it is a good game because it might very well be the only way a new generation of players learns about modern warfare.”
89/100 – Review by Dean Takahashi
Title: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare
Developer: Infinity Ward
Release date: October 25, 2019
Platform: PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One
Visit our new releases section for more on this week’s new video games.
We have a favour to ask
Thumbsticks has a couple of main aims. We want to write interesting articles and cover games that most outlets won't, and we want to give opportunities to new writers and new voices. And right now, with the current state of online publishing? It's tough! We hate to ask, but if you want us to continue writing what others won't, or to keep covering weird indie games, or to be able to give opportunities to new writers – and only if you can afford it – then please consider supporting us on Patreon.
Recommended for you
Latest from Thumbsticks
New PlayStation Store releases: December 6-10, 2021
Here's a quick roundup of this week's lineup of new PlayStation Store releases for the PS4 and PS5.
New Nintendo Switch releases: December 6-10, 2021
Loop Hero and Life is Strange: True Colors headline this week's lineup of new Nintendo Switch eShop releases.
New Xbox releases: December 6-10, 2021
Upcoming Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One releases include Halo Infinite and Rune Factory 4 Special.
Three great games are free to play on Xbox this weekend.
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate and Xbox Live Gold members can play three new games for free until Sunday.
Here are the Xbox Games with Gold for December
In case you missed it, here are the four games available through Xbox Games with Gold in December 2021.
Pac-Man – Birth of an Icon review
Pac-Man - Birth of an Icon details the meteoric rise of Namco's groundbreaking arcade game in glorious, vivid detail.
13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim Nintendo Switch release date confirmed
13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim, the critically acclaimed strategy adventure game from Vanillaware, will be released for Nintendo Switch in April...
Icarus from DayZ creator Dean Hall is out this week
Icarus is the latest title from Dean Hall's post-DayZ studio. Will it fly too close to the sun like DayZ...