Connect with us
Advertisement

Reviews

Oceanhorn: Monster of Uncharted Seas review – Nintendo Switch

Let’s start by tackling the obvious question. Is Oceanhorn – Monster of Uncharted Seas a Zelda rip-off?

Published

on

Oceanhorn - Artwork

Let’s start by tackling the obvious question. Is Oceanhorn – Monster of Uncharted Seas a Zelda rip-off?

Listing just a few of the game’s elements will paint a familiar picture: An ancient tree, a blue-shirted young hero, heart pieces to collect, jars to smash, boxes to push, and torches to light. It’s all there. It even has a wise owl NPC, a boat to sail, and a McGuffin called the Triforce, sorry, the Triloth. It’s blatant, and, on occasion, brazenly shameless.

Yet, Nintendo doesn’t seem to mind Oceanhorn being sold on the eShop, so perhaps we should assume it’s not quite the copycat we think.

Advertisement

Calling Oceanhorn a Zelda game suggests that it displays a modicum of design, pacing, and humour, or has fun combat, devious boss encounters, a sense of adventure, and memorable moments of puzzle-solving gameplay. And it, for the most part, it doesn’t.

So, despite the familiar feel, it’s obvious why Nintendo doesn’t mind. Oceanhorn simply doesn’t bear comparison with even the most tepid of Link’s adventures.

Oceanhorn was originally released on iOS in 2013, a time when mobile gaming appeared to threaten the traditional console experience, with disastrous consequences expected for Nintendo. It was an example of a mobile game that really looked the part and, at first glance, played as well as it looked.

Fast forward four years, and that future doesn’t seem quite so inevitable. Nintendo has a finger in the mobile pie, and a renewed sense of purpose with its console/handheld hybrid. By arriving on Switch in the wake of Breath of the Wild, Oceanhorn now feels positively ancient.

Advertisement

Oceanhorn - Triloth

The game remains eye-catching, serving up a glossy isometric diorama to explore that evokes a Playmobil toy set, but in terms of gameplay it lacks variety and urgency. Oceanhorn finds a closer cousin in the tedious split-level cave networks of the Pokémon series than it does in Zelda’s dungeons.

The game’s rudimentary gameplay betrays its touch screen origins, leading to one note combat, simple puzzles, and a general lack of tension. Add in some poor sign-posting, and longer play sessions can feel aimless and draining. Playing in handheld mode helps, making the experience feel more aligned to the game’s limited scope. And compared to the mobile version, it does have the obvious advantage of traditional console controls.

That suggests Oceanhorn controls well, but, adding to its litany of annoyances, it doesn’t. Movement feels floaty and vague, another reminder that it was a game made for thumbs and not thumb sticks.

Oceanhorn, therefore, falls between the gaps. It’s an attempt to replicate the console experience on mobile, that now finds itself unable to live up to its inspiration when given the full set of tools.

And yet, it’s not entirely without merit.

Oceanhorn - Sailing

Firstly, the game has exemplary production values. The visuals, as mentioned, work well, especially on the small screen. The music is also rather beautiful, featuring contributions from Nobou Uemtsu. (Tellingly, his name is the first on the opening titles, a sure sign of where developer Cornfox & Bros spent a good chunk of the game’s budget.)

Advertisement
Advertisement

It’s also well acted – although our hero has a strangely mature voice for such a small lad – and where Cornfox & Bros depart from the Zelda template by adding their own flourishes to age-old mechanics, the game is occasionally capable of creating its own magical moments.

Advertisement

If Oceanhorn was better priced – it’s £13.49 in the UK eShop, versus £7.99 on mobile – there’s a chance I might recommend it. On these warm summer days there’s an appeal in a game with low stakes that you can drift in and out of like a lazy afternoon nap. But the Nintendo Switch is not short of solid, polished mid-tier experiences, and your money will be better spent on the likes of Snake Pass, or the amazing remake of Wonder Boy The Dragon’s Trap.

Oceanhorn: Monster of Uncharted Seas
2

Summary

Oceanhorn is a game built from components so familiar that even Nintendo has tired of them. If the brief was to ‘Make a Zelda’ then Cornfox & Bros have only succeeded on a surface level. The studio evidently has talent – it’s a visual and aural treat – but due to the game’s mobile heritage, Oceanhorn on Switch feels compromised, vague, and ultimately forgettable.

Enjoyed this article?

We hope you found it useful, or informative, or thought provoking, or maybe even a little entertaining. Perhaps it was a guide that helped you through a tight spot, or we even saved you some money? Lovely stuff! If you'd like to say "thanks" you could always buy the team a cup of coffee.

Recommended for you

Thumbsticks editor and connoisseur of Belgian buns. Currently playing: Paper Mario: The Origami King, Animal Crossing: New Horizons, and Pikmin 3 Deluxe.

Advertisement

Latest from Thumbsticks

New Xbox One game releases New Xbox One game releases
News2 hours ago

New Xbox releases: September 20-24, 2021

The much-anticipated Sable and Yakuza spin-off sequel Lost Judgement are among the week's new Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One...

WarioWare: Get It Together! WarioWare: Get It Together!
Reviews23 hours ago

WarioWare: Get It Together! review

WarioWario: Let’s Get It Together! adds multiplayer and multiple characters to a fan favourite Nintendo franchise, but at what cost?

Thatcher's Techbase Thatcher's Techbase
News1 day ago

This Doom adventure lets you blast a reanimated Maggie Thatcher back to hell

In Doom-based adventure, Thatcher's Techbase, "Margaret Thatcher is back from Hell... and the lady's not for returning!"

Deltarune logo Deltarune logo
News2 days ago

Deltarune Chapter 2 release date revealed by Toby Fox

Deltarune Chapter 2 is almost upon us. We don't need to tell you to "please be excited" for this one.

Tux and Fanny video game Tux and Fanny video game
Features2 days ago

Surreal web cartoon Tux and Fanny makes for a sublime video game

In one day I went from not knowing a thing about Tux and Fanny to proclaiming it the best video...

Battlefield 2042 key art Battlefield 2042 key art
News2 days ago

Battlefield 2042 release date bumped to November

Electronic Arts has confirmed that the upcoming military shooter Battlefield 2042 will be released one month later than planned. EA says...

Age of Empires IV key art Age of Empires IV key art
News3 days ago

The developers want you to break Age of Empires IV this weekend

After a number of balloted tests, the floodgates will open for a limited-time, unrestricted stress test for Age of Empires...

Playstation Store Double Discounts Sale Playstation Store Double Discounts Sale
News3 days ago

The PlayStation Store Double Discounts sale returns

PS Plus members get double discounts on PS4 and PS5 games in the latest PlayStation Store video game sale.

Advertisement