Six months from its launch, my PlayStation 5 has been searching for a purpose.
I grew tired of Demon’s Souls, I finished Miles Morales in an afternoon, and Destruction Allstars was… well, it was Destruction Allstars. Yet as I have familiarized myself with the dangerous depths of Atropos, it became clear that the next-gen experience had finally arrived.
Returnal is the latest from Housemarque, the seasoned shoot-em-ups devs behind brilliant PS4 launch title Resogun, among others. Yet Returnal is a strange concoction of their arcade roots, AAA budgets, and the natural evolution of the roguelike.
The premise is simple. Selene, a planet scout, crashes on the “forbidden” planet of Atropos. She finds herself stuck in a loop that she must fight her way through. The immediate star is the H.R. Giger inspired, nightmarish environment of Atropos, which felt like the realised potential of the disappointing Alien Covenant. The dense maze is a feast for the eyes, as intimidating statues of alien beings stand tall, and monolithic structures hint at an impressive civilization long since gone. With sinister fog coating the floors, the darkly colourful enemies become all the more terrifying, especially as they send you packing right back to the start upon blasting you to death.
Unlike a lot of roguelikes, however, Returnal sinks its narrative hooks in, leaving you as intrigued narratively as you are for gameplay or setting. Why are you here? Why does Atropos morph on each run? Why is your 20th-century house slap bang in the middle of an alien planet? And who is the ominous Astronaut that stalks you from afar? Not everyone will be happy with the way in which these questions are answered, but they left me eager to delve once more into the dreaded loop.
Perhaps more surprising is that, at the fore of this story, is a tale of mental health. With audio logs found across Atropos – lying next to the scattered forbidding corpses of Selene’s past cycles – we get glimpses into the various mental states the endless cycle pushes her into. When she wakes, a reassuring “I’ve got to keep going” highlights Selene’s determination – not just to succeed, but to avoid the unrecognisable versions of herself that we hear over the audio logs.
And this determination, mixed with the cranking tension embedded into the roguelike genre, makes Returnal an absolute treat. The risk-reward consistently keeps you on your toes, and only bolsters the threat of the game’s impressive enemy types, which manage to stay fresh through the game’s entire run. You’ll constantly weigh up the pros and cons of your buffs and nerfs, which perks to purchase, and, most importantly, which guns to stick with.
And the latter isn’t necessarily an easy answer, as every weapon feels unique, results in a varied playstyle, and may work better for different scenarios ahead. One thing is for sure: their uniqueness is amped immeasurably by the excellent DualSense controller which, for the first time since Astro’s Playroom, feels properly realised in Returnal.
However, by this point you will no doubt have come across the dreaded discourse, surrounding the game’s save states – and it is a matter worth addressing. At the point of writing this review, Returnal does not allow players to save mid-run, and progression can only be kept after sessions via the PS5’s rest mode.
For someone like myself, who flits from game to game in a single sitting, this really impacted when I decided to play Returnal. Runs can greatly vary in lengths, but my last easily pushed past three hours – and it wasn’t unique.
For those with shorter gaming time available, it may seem like they are stuck in a loop themselves, never being able to progress beyond what their limited window will allow them. Couple this with the awful guidance of turning off auto-updates on the PS5 – a warning issued by Housemarque themselves – and the corruption of saves upon a recent update, Returnal seems to have designed a game so tightly around its premise, that it forgot how players actually play.
Almost to the point where it feels like its meta-roguelike nature extends beyond the gameplay and into playing the game itself. There’s roguelike, and then there’s roguelike, it seems. Returnal is extra in that regard.
Regardless of its convoluted saving structure, though, Returnal still feels like a promise fulfilled. A mind-numbingly beautiful, darkly enchanting and blisteringly fast game, that you would boot up just to show off your PS5 to your mates.
Platform: PlayStation 5 (reviewed)
Publisher: Sony Interactive Entertainment
Release Date: April 30, 2021
The £70 price tag may sting, but with close to 30 hours on a single playthrough and some of the most compelling gameplay I’ve experienced in a while, Returnal feels like a premium product worth every penny.
We have a favour to ask
Thumbsticks has a couple of main aims. We want to write interesting articles and cover games that most outlets won't, and we want to give opportunities to new writers and new voices. But it's hard to do that in the current financial climate. If you'd like to help us fund these aims, you could always buy the team a cup of coffee.
Latest from Thumbsticks
Blade Runner: Enhanced Edition is out now on PC and console
The updated version of Westwood Studios' classic Blade Runner game is available now on all platforms.
FIFA 22 and Naraka: Bladepoint are now on Xbox Game Pass
FIFA 22 and Naraka: Bladepoint complete June's impressive Xbox Game Pass lineup.
Reminder: There’s a new Nintendo Direct today
JRPG fans should set their alarms for today's Nintendo Direct broadcast.
Fall Guys is out now on Xbox and Nintendo Switch
Battle Royale platformer Fall Guys is out now – and free to play – on Xbox and Nintendo Switch.
This week’s PlayStation releases (June 20-24, 2022)
This week's lineup of new PlayStation releases is dominated by compilations and remasters of classic video games.
This week’s Xbox releases (June 20-24, 2022)
Fall Guys, The Elder Scrolls, and Sonic the Hedgehog headline this week's lineup of new Xbox releases.
This week’s Nintendo Switch releases (June 20-24, 2022)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder's Revenge and Neon White headline this week's list of Nintendo Switch eShop releases.
Capcom confirms that Dragon’s Dogma 2 is in development
Capcom has announced that Dragon’s Dogma 2 is now in development.